click to close
help
edit

Forums
Finance

Transfer student loan to a credit card?

  • filter:
  • Tell A Friend
  • Text Only
  • Search this Topic »
  • switch to 'Classic' view
  • Go to Page :
  • 1 2
rated:
alert mods    

I have approximately 10k in private student loans at 11.5%. I have excellent credit and would be able to pay this off in 1-2 years. What are some of my options to transfer this to a low or no interest credit card? Would it have to start as a cash advance to pay off the loan? The loan is held by a local "non profit" corporation. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks in advance,
Ben

Quick Summary is created and edited by users like you... Add FAQ's, Links and other Relevant Information by clicking the edit button in the lower right hand corner of this message.


rated:
alert mods    

You can either balance transfer the money directly to the lender or to your checking account and pay it off that way. Remember to do a balance transfer that way you won't pay silly cash advance fees and APR.

And check your BT APR and term length to make sure you are comfortable with it.

Read up on A-O-R, you could probably pay it off quick that way.

Message edited by: mewannaxbox on 2008-04-11 22:10:26 CDT
rated:
alert mods    

I don't know much about student loans, but how about refinancing / consolidating for a lower rate?

Transfering your debt to credit cards is very similar to engaging in a BT arbitrage. The additional risks you are taking by transfering your student loans (instead of just taking cash out of credit cards and investing in savings accounts) are:

1. shortening the duration of your debt (14 or however many years vs. 1 year),
2. from fixed rate / fixed payment to variable rate (of course, the variable rate is 0% to begin with, but what if you can't pay off on time).

I know that the oppty cost of NOT transfering your student loan to credit cards is 11% - 3.5% or whatever you can get by investing in HY savings or CDs, that's why I suggested lowering your rate by consolidating, and then, separately, engaging in BT arbitrage.

rated:
alert mods    

It's a private student loan so consolidation isn't going to help much. A credit card makes sense here considering the amount involved. You probably wont be able to discharge it in bankruptcy, at least not for a long while, but I assume you're not looking for that option considering it's only 10k. Just make sure you don't forget about the card and pay it off when it's time to do so.

rated:
alert mods    

As others have said, if your credit is good you should not have a problem using a credit card promotional rate to balane transfer and directly pay off the student loan.

Just be sure to follow up with the student loan company. Get it in writing that the loan has been paid off.

Also, keep in mind that credit card debt is much less flexible than student loan debt. You cannot easily put a credit card payment in deferrment should your financial situation change, and in fact, if you are late on even one payment you will lose the promotional rate entirely.

So...keep track of your due dates carefully, make sure your finances are in order ... then go for it.

rated:
alert mods    

I'm not sure OP can put the private student loan in deferment either.

If payoff in two years is feasible, I don't see much downside in converting 11.5% to 0% for a year. Even if OP ends up paying interest in year two, the balance will be less than $5,000, and should be able to find something with an interest rate less than 11.5%.

rated:
alert mods    

OP, I was able to transfer my student loan balance to a credit card with low APR for the life of the loan. As the above posters suggest, you have to weigh the (potentially) decreased interest against increased risk relative to deferment and changing of account terms at creditors' discretion. The trade-off has worked for me using Chase. Good luck!

rated:
alert mods    

Apply for some 0% cards. Note that your monthly payments may be as high as 4% of the balance (up to $400/month). After the 10 months of the 0% offer pass, see if you can apply for some more 0% or low BT rate cards. Apply for business cards so you can hide the balance from your personal credit report. It won't be a cash advance- a Balance Transfer.

rated:
alert mods    

I just did this for two of my wife's previously higher-interest student loans.

Works great, if you are sure you can pay it off by the time the balance transfer offer expires (or find another offer).

Beware the tax implications, as you might have a hard time deducting any interest as student loan interest. But at 0%, who cares?

Message edited by: JimTravel73 on 2008-04-12 15:50:43 CDT
rated:
alert mods    

You can't consolidate private student loans? I'd double check on that first if I were you. If you can consolidate with Federal Direct you might be able to get a very low APR. Under the terms of my consolidation loan, the APR is set every July 1 based on the rate of the 90-day T-bill, which I'm betting is going to be very low this year.

In any event, I have been considering doing what you're considering, and I haven't been able to make a decision one way or the other, mainly because there are many factors involved. Probably the biggest one is this: will you be able to pay off the entire balance immediately if things go pear shaped? For example: you miss a payment and your CC hikes your APR to 23%? If so, then go for it. Once you get the balance onto CCS, it's just a matter of seeing how long you can carry the balance at 0%. At that rate, there's really no incentive for you to pay it off (other than the probably negligible effect on your credit score).

As others have advised, you should read some of the other threads here to make sure you understand all the factors involved. There are a few concerning how to get money from your CC into your bank account. Some CCS make it easy, others impossible. Citibank has always made it easy by providing checks for balance transfers; you can log into your account and request a BT check be sent to you. If your credit is as good as you say, you should have no trouble getting a Citi card with a $10K credit line and a 0% BT for a year with no fees.

rated:
alert mods    

Grantspy said:You can't consolidate private student loans? I'd double check on that first if I were you. If you can consolidate with Federal Direct you might be able to get a very low APR. Under the terms of my consolidation loan, the APR is set every July 1 based on the rate of the 90-day T-bill, which I'm betting is going to be very low this year.

I'm pretty sure you can only consolidate federal loans

rated:
alert mods    

You can consolidate private loans, but you just end up another private loan.

If you can go back to school and have someone else pay for it, you can do what a friend of mine is doing. She's working on a master's degree on her company's dime. However, she's applying for financial aid and qualifying for Stafford loans (mostly unsubsidized, but still). She is taking the money from the Stafford loans and paying down her private loans. So, she'll turn that nasty private stuff into federal loans, with all of the advantages.

rated:
alert mods    

aldihelper said:I have approximately 10k in private student loans at 11.5%. I have excellent credit and would be able to pay this off in 1-2 years. What are some of my options to transfer this to a low or no interest credit card? Would it have to start as a cash advance to pay off the loan? The loan is held by a local "non profit" corporation. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks in advance,
Ben

They do not sound very "non profit" to me.

rated:
alert mods    

I've done this with two private loans from school, each around 10K. One was with Citi and one with FNBO and both have 1.9% for the life of the balance transfer. Compared to 8.5% the loan was at, it was a no brainer. Both Citi and FNBO let you set up automatic withdrawals from your checking or savings account for the minimum payment each month. I can tell you there is absolutely no difference between when i was paying the private loan company vs. the CC company. The payment comes out each month like clockwork and i don't even notice it. The savings over the next 10 years is enormous and well outweighs the student loan interest deduction. That 11.5% rate is enormous, even over 2 years. Run the numbers on some of the online interest calculators and you'll see exactly how much you'll save and if it's worth it to you. Again, it was utterly painless for me and, if you are very responsible with money and will set up the automatic withdrawals, it's a no brainer.

rated:
alert mods    

is it just the benefit of the lower interest rate or can you earn benefits on the balance transfer (miles, Cash Back, gift cards)?

i've never done a balance transfer so I didn't know if they counted for that kind of thing.

rated:
alert mods    

tangent1138 said:is it just the benefit of the lower interest rate or can you earn benefits on the balance transfer (miles, Cash Back, gift cards)?

i've never done a balance transfer so I didn't know if they counted for that kind of thing.

Most of the time, you get nothing but a lower rate for balance transfers

rated:
alert mods    

I too have been thinking of doing this with some of my wife's high interest rate student loans. One thing to think about if you are doing this for a spouse -- although somewhat morbid -- is that if you transfer these amounts to a credit card via BT, you lose the implicit death benefit embedded in many student loans. Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but most federal and private loans can be discharged upon death (assuming they are only held in your spouses name). If, God forbid, you transfer say $10k of of your spouses student loans to a credit card and the next day they get in a car accident -- that's $10k you will still be expected to pay off to the credit card company, which you wouldn't be expected to pay on the student loan. This was somewhat of an issue to me until I recently acquired some term life insurance for the two of us -- now we're not as concerned about paying off an extra $10,000 if something terrible were to happen. Just something else to think about if you're considering this type of arbitrage.

rated:
alert mods    

Absolutely right on the the death benefit issue as stated above. This should be factored in when figuring your life insurance needs as the benefit would need to cover the CC debt incurred.

rated:
alert mods    

sechs said:You can consolidate private loans, but you just end up another private loan.

If you can go back to school and have someone else pay for it, you can do what a friend of mine is doing. She's working on a master's degree on her company's dime. However, she's applying for financial aid and qualifying for Stafford loans (mostly unsubsidized, but still). She is taking the money from the Stafford loans and paying down her private loans. So, she'll turn that nasty private stuff into federal loans, with all of the advantages.

i don't know if that's technically legal, but it sure sounds wise.

 Close

Sign Me In
Nickname: 
Password: 
Remember My Login Information:

Forget your login information?

Not Already A Member?
Sign Up Now!

<