rated:
posted: Jul. 14, 2008 @ 2:03p
TXrex said:Instead of making a new thread, I'll ask my questions here.
I am thinking of buying a DSLR and it will be my first. Have always used point and shoot cameras before. I came down to 2 choices. Canon XSI or Canon 40D. The 40D is about 300 dollars more but I have heard it does a lot more. But I am a beginner to DSLR's and don't know if the extra bells and whistles will do me any good as a beginner. I don't mind the bigger size or weight.
Which one should I get? The XSI or 40D?I think you should spend as much time as you can looking around and reading this site That link takes you to the XSi page, but there are many many other pages crammed with info for you. In addition to that avalanche of information, the site has a helpful "ISO 12233 Resolution Chart crop sample comparison tool" (If I did this link correctly, it compares the XSi and the 40D).
I think Canon is a great choice in general, but for the extra money, I do not think that the 40D is worth it for you (based on the ridiculously small amount I know about you). 
IMO (and many may disagree which is okay, too), spend the difference on lenses and you will notice more improvement than between bodies - that is, until you go to a full frame sensor camera (Canon's 5D or 1DS Mk II or III).
I also believe that - although better equipment is capable of producing better results - there is something to be said for learning within the limitations of a basic DSLR.
Finally, if nothing else, the 40D weighs almost twice what the XSi does.
Best of luck, and have fun no matter what you get.
Message edited by: jidteach on 2008-07-14 14:04:48 CDT